HL Tech Biz Exclusive: Is Tim Cook's Apple Past Its Peak

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Justin Sullivan / Getty Images

Following Apple’s first down quarter in over a decade and mixed reviews for the company’s recent Worldwide Developers Conference, an ominous question is making the rounds.

Has Apple peaked?

Ask four people this question, and you’ll get four different answers.

“Apple peaked when [former CEO Steve] Jobs died,” said venture capitalist and tech writer Dileep Rao. “No one has been able to succeed with Apple's business model except Jobs. Tim Cook is a nice guy (as we always say in Minnesota), but he is no Steve Jobs.”

Tech entrepreneur Jerome Hardaway had a different peak in mind – in 2001, after the company released it’s first iPod. “It showcased an ability to enter new markets with fresh ideas and a true understanding of the consumer."

“I would say Apple’s peak, innovation-wise, was following the launch of the iPhone in 2007,” said Sagi Gidali, co-founder and CPO of SaferVPN. “This product was unlike anything else seen in the mobile arena and truly revolutionized the role of cellphones and popularity of personal devices.”

Tech writer Tayven James points to a far more recent peak. “It came at the time of the iPhone 6 launch in September of 2014,” he said. “The months following Apple's 2014 Keynote event marked the most profitable in Apple's history. iPhone 6 sales numbers led to the high-water mark for Apple's stock value.”

So which is it? Did Apple peak the day it launched the iPod? Right before Jobs died?

Graphiq sites SpecOut and FindTheCompany teamed up to break down eight different ways of thinking about Apple’s peak, some more data-driven, others more anecdotal.

Perspective No. 1: Cook vs. Jobs

Perhaps the most common critique against the modern-day Apple — at least when it comes to assessing the company’s peak — matches Rao’s opinion. Namely, that the corporation was better off under Steve Jobs than Tim Cook.

Jobs was an innovator, Cook merely a supply chain manager, or so the argument goes. As such, fans of this perspective will argue that Apple was at its peak shortly before Jobs died.

The problem: Most of the financial metrics contradict this perspective, as we'll see in a few examples below.

Perspective No. 2: Stock Price

In contrast to Rao’s perspective is James’ focus on stock price. In the world of investing, stock price is arguably the best proxy for public opinion on a company. The higher the price investors are willing to pay, the more confident they are in the future of the business.

By this measure, Apple’s peak was quite recent: early 2015. The company had just recorded record sales during the 2014 holiday quarter, smashing analysts’ expectations with 74.5 million iPhones sold in just three months. That was nearly 50 percent more than the 2013 holiday quarter, which had also been a record.

Proponents of this perspective will point out that Apple’s stock price has more than doubled since Jobs’ death.

Perspective No. 3: Revenue

The stock market can be fickle, however, as investors react based on their expectations, rather than the raw dollars. As such, some might point to Apple’s quarterly revenue as the best way to measure Apple’s success over time.

Here, it seems Apple is doing about as well as it ever has, with $75-billion peaks during holiday quarters and $50 billion each quarter throughout the rest of the year. For context, that’s more than three times the revenue, on average, that Apple was making the quarter the iPad first launched in April 2010.

Perspective No. 4: Year-Over-Year Growth

Revenue skeptics might respond by pointing to Apple’s trajectory, rather than its raw totals. It’s one thing to make $50 billion; it’s another to grow revenue by 50 percent year over year.

Take a look at the same visualization, this time with year-over-year growth noted in the gray line. By this measure, Apple has been growing a lot more slowly — and sometimes declining — since mid-2012.

Apple’s single strongest quarter of year-over-year growth came in Q4 of 2010, when Apple grew revenue more than 100 percent year over year (note that these are fiscal quarters, so Q4 represents July through September). Part of this massive change is due to Apple’s inconsistent iPhone release months, which makes comparing year over year changes somewhat misleading prior to 2011, after which releases became more standardized.

Still, Apple maintained 50 percent year-over-year growth from early 2010 through mid 2012 — a remarkable feat, and enough to argue that Apple may have peaked during this time. This growth was largely fueled by the iPad, which launched in March 2010. The iPad created a whole new product category for Apple, and it sold even faster than the iPhone in its first few years of existence.

But iPad growth would plateau by 2014, which leads us to the next perspective.

Perspective No. 5: Health of Apple’s Three Major Product Lines

Despite the iPhone’s historic growth in 2015, the iPad had begun to decline, taking with it some of Apple’s luster and a bit of investor confidence.

From a strictly bottom-line perspective, the iPhone more than made up for the iPad’s decline in 2015. But a diverse product line can help insulate a business from disruption, and relying too heavily on the iPhone could be risky. With this in mind, Apple has arguably been in some form of decline since late 2013, thanks to the declining iPad.

Perspective No. 6: Pace of Innovative Product Launches

Speaking of the iPad, some — like Hardaway and Gidali — gauge Apple’s success by its frequency or quality of successful product line releases. Since Steve Jobs’ return to Apple in 1997, the company has released the iMac (1998), iPod (2001), MacBook (2006), Apple TV (2006), iPhone (2007), iPad (2010) and the Watch (2015).

Here, you could argue that Apple peaked around 2006 and 2007, when the company began three new product lines, including its most successful of all: the iPhone.

Still, which products truly count as breakthrough innovations? Does the Apple TV belong in the same breath as the iPad? Apple has often called its TV product a “hobby.” And what about all the products not mentioned here, from iTunes to the Magic Trackpad?

And finally, how do you measure iteration against innovation? Does Apple deserve more credit for the release of the brand new Apple Watch, or eight straight years of iPhone refinements? The former launched a whole new product line, but the latter has resulted in many times more sales.

Perspective No. 7: The Past

None of the products above even account for the early days of Apple, which revolutionized computing with the Apple II and Macintosh. Business-wise, Apple’s early years can’t compare to its 21st century record smashing. But in terms of influence, perhaps Apple’s peak came in the late ‘70s and early ‘80s.

Perspective No. 8: The Future

Finally, there’s the future. Perhaps Apple’s brightest days are still ahead. Rumors continue to swirl about a potential Apple Car, and the company has been suspiciously quiet about virtual reality, despite big moves in the space from rivals Facebook, Google and Microsoft. With billions in reserve, Apple could compete just about anywhere, given sufficient motivation.

Consider that Apple has never invested more in research and development, having grown the budget more than 30 percent for six years running. Clearly, the future is very much on the company's mind.

But can Apple really ever match the success that was the iPhone, and, temporarily, the iPad? Take Tim Cook’s own thoughts in a 2014 interview with the Wall Street Journal. Asked about Apple's slowing growth, Cook referred back to 2010 through 2012 — just after the iPad's release and during the iPhone's rapid rise.

“We were in hyper-growth, or whatever is above growth. We went from $65 billion to over $100 billion to $150 billion to $170 billion. These are historic, unprecedented numbers. I don’t know any companies adding growth at that level. So when you say $14 billion to $15 billion compared to those numbers, it’s clearly smaller and a smaller percentage, but, to put it in some context, that’s like adding three Fortune 500 companies in a year. I think that’s hard to say that’s not a growth company.”

In the end, Apple’s past success deserves some blame for the intense scrutiny the company garners today. Any recent, incremental growth tends to look small and underwhelming by comparison.

Research Over 30M Companies on FindTheCompany

Haute Tease

  • The Peanut Butter Falcon Review - Beautiful, Captivating, A Feel-Good Film That Inspires

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Peanut Butter Falcon, from Roadside Attractions, presents the story of new beginnings, as the paths of three unique and lost souls, a Downs Syndrome orphan, an unemployed fisherman, and a social worker, cross on a wild adventure.

  • Spectacular Art Deco Emeralds and Magnificent Diamonds Headline Bonhams First London Fine Jewellery Sale Of 2018

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Set to be some of the most talked about lots in Bonhams London Fine Jewellery sale next month (25 April) are three outstanding Art Deco jewels by Hennell who closed its doors for good in 2001.

  • Griffin’s Kiosk – A Secure Display Mount for iPad Use in Retail and Commercial Setting

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Griffin Technology, one of the world’s foremost creators of innovations for everyday life, has announced the immediate availability of Kiosk, a secure display mount for all iPad models.


    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Thomas Eric Duncan, the first diagnosed case of Ebola Haemorrhagic Fever, has died in a Dallas hospital less than two weeks after arriving in the United States from Liberia, the West African nation engulfed in a pandemic.

  • Orlando Shooting Fuels Debate on Gun Control

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Early Sunday morning, right around last call, a gunman walked into a gay nightclub in Orlando, Florida, and opened fire with an assault rifle and handgun, killing 49 people and injuring 53.  

  • Kings of Beer Review - Grab a Bud, Channel Paul Newman and Take a Long, Cool, Refreshing, Sip

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Kings of Beer, from Gravitas Ventures and Ace Content, presents the hidden secrets from inside the majestic and storied walls of Anheuser-Busch breweries as the Master Breweries from each bottling factory vie for the title of King of Beer.

  • Actor Scott Patterson Evokes Americana Diner Culture With Launch Of Scotty P's Big Mug Coffee

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Paying homage to the Americana diner culture and the universal liquid medium of family and friendship, actor/entrepreneur Scott Patterson, best-known as diner owner Luke Danes on the hit television series "Gilmore Girls," has launched Scotty P's Big Mug Coffee.  

  • Celebrate The Holiday Season in New York City

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    New York City at Christmas, glittering lights decorate every tree, hope is alive and the unexpected holiday feelings move strangers into random acts of kindness, the city lights up with multi-colored memories of Christmas’ past.

  • Beltway Insider: Trump, Allies Bomb Syria; Paul Ryan Retires; Gay Serial Killer; Ingraham Loses Another; Milos Forman

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Donald Trump, British Prime Minister Theresa May and French President Emmanuel Macron united against Syrian President Bashar al-Assad use of chemical weapons launched strategic airstrikes against the dictatorial leader's weapons strongholds in the capital of Damascus.

  • Blood Review – A Bone Chilling, Arresting, Thriller

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Blood,” from BBC Films and Lipsync Productions, presents, spine tingling, chilling mystery thriller that weaves haunted memories with the cat and mouse chase that is unexpectedly stunning from the beginning.

  • Mile 22 Review - An Action Packed Race Against Time CIA Thriller

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Mile 22, from STX Entertainment, brings to the screen a contemporary, high tech espionage story focusing on a special active CIA team traveling the globe answering the call when hot situations threaten the safety and security of America.

  • Op/Ed: Call Me, Harvey. I’ll Defend You – Millionaire Madam Lawyer, Norm Pattis, Offers a Different Opinion

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Not since Meg Ryan’s fake orgasm sitting across a diner’s table from Billy Crystal in “When Harry Met Sally”  have we seen such disingenuous huffing and puffing about sex from Hollywood.

  • Beltway Insider: Trump Tax Overhaul; Obama/Hezbollah; EU MeToo; Philippine Tragedies; Miss America CEO; Christmas

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Donald Trump ended his first calendar year in office by signing an historic tax overhaul bill, marking his first legislative victory and jump starting his reelection campaign, in what he calls Making America Great Again.

  • Ivanka Trump, Husband, and Family Heckled on Commercial Flight

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Ivanka Trump, the power-hungry daughter of President-elect Trump, flew commercial this week, along with husband Jared Kushner and their three children only to be heckled, harassed and lambasted by fellow passengers still angry over the election.

  • Beltway Insider: Trump/Merkel Meet; Clinton; Paris; Brexit; Border Wall; Conway/DOJ; Chuck Barry

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Donald Trump, arguably the most recognized blowhard in Washington, was superseded this week by Winter Storm Stella, a bombogenesis, that barreled up the eastern seaboard closing government and postponing the first visit with German Chancellor Angela Merkel.