Slenderman Tween Found Incompetent to Stand Trial; Legal Commentary By Whitey Bulger Defense Attorney Hank Brennan

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Morgan Geyser, 12, known as one half of the Slenderman Killers, who stabbed a twelve year old friend 19 times, has been found incompetent to stand trial for her participation in the crimes that shocked this tiny Wisconsin city.

Geyser, who was identified by the victim as her "best friend" along with Anissa Wier, also 12, allegedly meticulously planned the May 31 attack luring the victim to a park, where they repeatedly stabbed her, narrowly missing her major arteries, and leaving her for dead in a cult sacrifice devotion killing to prove allegiance and loyalty to the fictional Slenderman.

The victim suffered internal, although not life threatening, injuries with stab wounds on her stomach, pancreas, and liver. Physicians indicated the child's heart had also been touched, but not penetrated, by the knife.

The victim, whose identity has not been released, has repeatedly stated her desire to live was the force that propelled her as she crawled from the scene to a bike path where she was found.

The two preteens have been charged with two counts of Attempted First Degree murder and face up to sixty years in prison.

The appalling, sophisticated, pre-mediated crime that garnered international publicity included code words used throughout the three month planning stage and pre-arranged "go" phrases and words that would initiate the stabbing.

Although motive has been placed on an allegiance to the fictional character seen on the reward the girls expected for their devotion has never been discussed. At arrest they were walking toward Nicolet National Forest, where they believed Slenderman lived in a Mansion.

Legal Commentary

Hank Brennan, co-defense attorney in the recent trial, and lead counsel in the appellate process, for James "Whitey" Bulger, the notorious Boston Mobster, explained and clarified the recent decision and ruling.

"In the 'Slenderman' case, the defense obtained an expert who evaluated the accused and determined that she was "mentally incompetent to proceed with her defense."  This is the pre-trial assertion that the trial should not even occur.  Since the defense made the assertion, the prosecutor is entitled to have their own doctor, or, depending on the jurisdiction, one appointed by the court, to evaluate the accused to determine competency." 

What then? "After the prosecutor's expert reports their findings the court will have a hearing and both sides can introduce witnesses, expert testimony, and other evidence to support their position.  Ultimately, the court will decide whether the accused is competent to stand trial.  If the Court determines the accused is competent to stand trial there will be a trial.  If there is a trial the defense may pursue mental defect as a partial or total defense to the charges."

Isn't that simply a way out? "If the court determines that the defendant is incompetent to stand trial a number of things can happen.  Depending on the jurisdiction, a judge can take steps to assist the accused in gaining competency through medication, treatment, or other means.  Typically, an accused will remain incarcerated in a secure mental health facility during this period.  In most jurisdictions, an accused can be incarcerated, usually at a mental health facility until they become competent.  Sometimes an accused will remain incarcerated until they die if they never achieve competency.  In other jurisdictions, a person can be released if they are deemed incompetent to stand trial.  If an accused is deemed incompetent to stand trial there is a regular period of review by a doctor to determine if the competency issue has changed.  Each jurisdiction has specific rules relative to competency and the procedures that are followed if someone is deemed incompetent.  In some jurisdictions the rules can provide a judge discretion to choose release or continued incarceration."

About 10 years ago, co-counsel on Bulger, J.W. Carney Jr. and I tried a murder case where the defendant had at one point been deemed not competent to stand trial. (He was acquitted of murder and convicted of manslaughter.) He remained incarcerated for many years.  He was diagnosed with cancer and shortly after his diagnosis a doctor determined that he was competent to stand trial.  A few years ago, in Massachusetts, a judge concluded that a man accused of first degree murder was incompetent to stand trial and there were no programs or likelihood of competence and in consequence released the accused and dismissed the charges."

Slenderman was originally created as a fictional character, unusually tall, thin, featureless, the slender man was created in 2009 and went viral with unrelated authors using the fictional characters in various artistic expression predominately horror assigning fantasies of abduction primarily of children or other child directed crimes.

The girls have maintained they believed the character was real.  

Hank Brennan, previously a District Attorney in Suffolk and Essex Counties, he received accommodations for his trial advocacy from the Suffolk Law School and American Bar Association Brennan joined the Bulger Defense team in 2011 and conducted the majority of the cross examinations during the trial.


Haute Tease

  • Emotional Anorexia: Why Others Think you are Difficult

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Relationships are not simple. In fact, the closer your association with someone, the more complicated the relationship. In any relationship, one person's needs and expectations intersect with the other person's needs and expectations.

  • Taiwan Earthquake: 14 Confirmed Dead, Dozens Injured, Scores Missing

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    It has been 24 hours since the 6.4 magnitude killer earthquake struck Tainan, a southern city on the island of Taiwan in the South China Sea, leaving 14 confirmed dead, dozens injured, scores missing and massive structural damage.

  • Ben Affleck, Jessica Chastain, Viola Davis, Kevin Hart, Shirley Maclaine, Chris Pine, Miles Teller and Naomi Watts to Present At 87th Oscars®

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Ben Affleck, Jessica Chastain, Viola Davis, Kevin Hart, Shirley MacLaine, Chris Pine, Miles Teller and Naomi Watts will be presenters at this year’s Oscars, show producers Craig Zadan and Neil Meron announced today. The Oscars, hosted by Neil Patrick Harris, will air on Sunday, February 22, 2015 live on ABC.  

  • Academy Orchestrates Oscar® Concert Celebrating Nominated Scores And Songs

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    BEVERLY HILLS, CA -  For the first time as part of its annual Oscar Week events, the Academy will present a live "Oscar Concert" celebrating this year's nominated scores and songs on Thursday, February 27, at 8 p.m. at UCLA's Royce Hall.

  • The Academy Elects 2014–15 Board Of Governors

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    LOS ANGELES, CA – Five first-time governors have been elected to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences Board of Governors.  In addition, eight incumbents have been reelected and four previous governors are returning to the Board. 

  • TWA Flight 800 Review – Exposing The Shocking FBI Cover-Up

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    “TWA Flight 800,” an investigative documentary into the July 17, 1996 explosion of the Paris bound 747, presents concrete evidence that destroys the government’s pre-packaged findings and neatly presented conclusion.


    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    BEVERLY HILLS, CA – The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences today announced that 11 live action short films will advance in the voting process for the 85th Academy Awards®.  A tie in the nominations balloting resulted in 11 films being shortlisted.  One hundred twenty-five pictures had originally qualified in the category.