Tech News: 22 Big Tech Brands Ranked from First to Worst

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
AFP / Stringer / Getty Images

When you hear the name of a popular tech brand, you’ll naturally have a gut reaction. Perhaps you love Sony’s game consoles, but can’t stand its headphones. Or maybe you buy Samsung exclusively, whether it’s a smartphone, tablet or refrigerator.

Maybe you’re married Apple products? And then there’s Casio—which you might associate with decent cameras, bad smartphones and cheap-but-passable wristwatches.

Some of this comes from actual product experience, but more often, it’s all about the marketing. Microsoft spends millions trying to win over young professionals. Every Apple ad tells us they have superior design. Even that $20 drug store Casio watch is in your head for a reason—a timepiece advertised as the go-to option for people on a budget.

But which brands truly measure up to the marketing? At SpecOut, we rated thousands of products across dozens of product categories, from smartphones to tablets, cameras to headphones, televisions to washing machines. We then determined the average rating for each brand within each product category. Finally, we created an overall ranking based on each brand's performance across all product categories.

After we reveal the overall rankings and explain our methodology, we’ll chart the ratings for a few key brands in greater detail.

The Methodology

How did you determine the product ratings?

Each product received a Smart Rating, based on expert reviews, benchmark performance, specifications and features. To take smartphones as an example, we factored in expert scores (CNET, Laptop Mag, PC Magazine, PC World, WIRED), over a dozen tech specs (battery life, video resolution, pixel density, etc.) and a variety of performance benchmarks (Geekbench, Basemark OS II, CamSpeed, DxO Mark, GFXBench, Broswermark).

How did you settle on these 22 brands?

We only included brands that sell products in at least four of the product categories we cover.

Which product categories did you include?

We covered a total of 22 product categories.

  • Digital cameras
  • Digital pianos
  • Dryers
  • E-readers
  • Fitness trackers
  • Game consoles
  • Headphones
  • Laptops
  • Motherboards
  • Processors (CPUs)
  • Printers
  • Refrigerators
  • Smartphones
  • Smartwatches
  • Solid state drives
  • Streaming media players
  • Tablets
  • Televisions
  • Vacuums
  • Video graphics cards
  • Washing machines
  • Wireless speakers

Most brands make products in just five or six of these categories. In contrast, Samsung, Sony, LG and Panasonic cover at least 10 each. The following chart breaks down the number of relevant categories for each of the 22 brands.

Why did you use standard deviation in the final ranking?

Some product categories (like tablets) feature a huge diversity of options, features and quality, leading to a wide range of ratings, from terrible (20/100) to phenomenal (100/100). Meanwhile, other product categories (like processors), have hundreds of similar offerings, with only minor differences in speed and performance, leading to a clump of close ratings.

As such, standard deviation allows us to determine which brands truly stand out (both positively and negatively), regardless of how clumped or widespread the ratings in each product category tend to be.

Key Takeaways

Amazon

Amazon emerges as the surprise winner, the brand with the most consistently high quality of the pack. The company’s secret? Restraint. Amazon doesn’t bother making products in categories where it can’t compete, which means few products drag down the brand’s overall score. The company is better than average across all categories, from e-readers (best in the business) to streaming media players (top tier) to wireless speakers (solid).

Yes, the Fire Phone was a verifiable sales flop, but the device wasn’t nearly as terrible as the tech world likes to remember. The handset can’t compete with the Samsung's Galaxy S6, but the Fire Phone is still a lot more capable than many of Samsung’s other devices, an assembly line of bloated hardware at basement pricing.

Apple

Apple checks in at No. 2, with stellar ratings in the categories you’d expect: phones, tablets, smartwatches and laptops. But the brand stumbles with streaming media players (the Apple TV) and headphones, enough to knock the Cupertino titan out of first place. Perhaps the new Apple TV can boost the company’s media player ratings.

Samsung

In contrast to Apple and Amazon—companies that carefully pick which product categories to pursue—Samsung pursues just about every market in the industry, from washing machines to printers to wireless speakers.

Here, Samsung’s home appliance bonafides stand out, with dryers and refrigerators ranking among the company’s most stand-out products.

For several other categories, Samsung’s hits (ex: the Galaxy S6) are weighed down by flops (ex: the Galaxy Grand Neo), typical of a company that follows a quantity-first mentality. But only when it comes to vacuums does Samsung truly stumble, coming far below average in an industry ruled by Dyson and Electrolux.

Hewlett-Packard

Near the other extreme of the spectrum is HP, the Palo Alto tech giant that just announced a 33,000-employee layoff. While HP’s products remain around average in two classic segments—printers and laptops—the brand has stumbled with smartphones and cameras. When your very best products are still only middle-of-the-road, that's not a good sign. As a result, HP winds up among the bottom three of our ranking.

Intel

When it comes to processors, Intel remains better than average—good news, given that so many mainstream laptops use Intel chips. Unfortunately, the brand falls short across other segments, from motherboards to solid state drives. Sometimes, it’s better to stick to what you’re good at, even if that’s just one thing. To Intel’s credit, they stopped producing motherboards in 2013.

The Most Crowded Product Category

At least among these 22 brands, the most crowded category isn’t smartphones or laptops, but tablets. The tablet industry appears to be a middle ground of sorts, a place where multiple tech titans can meet to compete in an enigmatic, unpredictable business. For now, Apple remains on top, while classic PC makers like Dell and Toshiba continue to struggle.

If there’s one company that seems to be building momentum, it’s Microsoft. Once a mobile outsider, the Redmond corporation has found a few new footholds with the Surface. That said, time will tell whether consumers actually start making the association. Sometimes, great products can be made in a year or two. But coaxing a positive gut reaction from consumers? That can take decades.

Compare Thousands of Tablets on SpecOut

Haute Tease

  • Election 2020: Surging Tom Steyer Campaigning in Southern Nevada

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Democratic presidential candidate Tom Steyer is in Las Vegas this weekend to energize his rapidly growing diverse coalition of voters ahead of the Nevada caucus. Tom’s son, Sam, continues the “It’s the Economy. #Battletested” bus tour through rural Nevada.  

  • Eddie V’s San Diego Review – Culinary Forward Seafood

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    "America's Finest City" just got a little tastier with the opening of Eddie V's San Diego location, adjacent to the waterfront Seaport Village dining and shopping complex, now serving delicious appetizing deep sea delights guaranteed to satisfy even the most sophisticated palette.

     
  • New York Fashion Week Coverage: Hiromi Asai Debuts Expanded Menswear Collection at the Upcoming IMG New York Fashion Week

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    HIROMI ASAI, a New York-based fashion designer and kimono stylist, is launching men's collection, made by Japanese high-end Kimono textiles, and presents it at the show room in New York during the upcoming New York Fashion Weeks.

     
  • Stanford Rape Case Addresses Frat Party Culture, Tolerance of Violence

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    A rape at Stanford University has become the focal point for the national conversation on sexual assault, after former Stanford swimmer Brock Turner received a sentence of six months jail time for a unanimous guilty verdict on three felony counts related to his assault of an unconscious woman outside a frat party.  

  • Steyer Calls on California to Pass Critical Police Reform Bills

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Climate activist, NextGen America founder, and former presidential candidate Tom Steyer released the following statement calling on the California state legislature to pass a suite of police reform bills including legislation to decertify police who become criminal offenders.

     
  • La Politique Par Le Vide

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Alors qu’approchent les élections régionales, se pose à nouveau la définition du macronisme. Philosophie politique à part entière ou mode de fonctionnement dédié à la survie d’un parti et de son chef de file, la question reste entière. Tentative d’explication.  

  • Widows Review - An Exceptional Whodunnit Thriller with Palpable Intrigue

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Widows, from 20th Century Fox, presents a fast moving political action thriller, set in contemporary Chicago, laced with corruption, intrigue, suspense, built around three avenging women left penniless after a heist gone bad leaves them widowed.

     
  • American Deterrence Restored: Israel Praises the Baghdadi Killing

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Israel, who has long used the strategy of targeted killings to keep the enemy on the run, is praising President Trump for his "bold, decisive action of targeting and killing of Abū Bakr al-Baghdadi," said Israeli Mayor David Rubin.

     
  • A LATE QUARTET, from Director Yaron Zilberman, Brilliantly Captures the World of Classical Performing Arts

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    A LATE QUARTET, from Opening Night Productions and Westend Films, delivers a magnificent emersion into the world of classical arts in the cultural Mecca of New York City.

     
  • IH NOM UH NIT Spring Summer 2019 Collection - Alluring, Provocative, Irresistible

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Luxury brand, IH NOM UH NIT, which has garnered an army of A-List fans, merges haute fashion with streetwear resulting in oversized, comfort combinations paired with top-notch accessories such as a signature leather sneaker collection and stylish sunglasses. 

     
  • HL London: The Extraordinary Faerground Accidents Release New Single “She Makes Me Want to Die”

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Signed to John Robb's Louder Than War Records, Faerground Accidents recently swept into my life, a parade of badly applied lipstick, gold cloaks, silver body paint and wine drunk straight from the bottle - and they've brought with them one of the most exciting new singles I've heard in ages!  

     
  • SPAIN Terror Attacks: Nation on High Alert as Twin Terror Attacks Leave 14 Dead; Hundreds Injured, 17 Critical

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Fourteen people are dead, and more than 100 injured after coordinated twin car/van ramming terror attacks, hours apart, struck the trendy tourist coastal city of Barcelona and Cambrils, a posh resort town 70 miles south.

     
  • Thanksgiving Box Office Round Up – After "The Irishman" Head to the Theater

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Thanksgiving weekend weather wise is a wash which spells stratospheric success for streaming giant Netflix and the premiere of Martin Scorsese’s The Irishman, the Jimmy Hoffa film from the master of American mobster movies.

     
  • Crime City USA: The Top Thirty Murder Capitals

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Crime rates are decreasing across large cities in the United States, but murder rates are on the rise.  

  • Le Royaume-Uni céda…

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Pour mettre fin à la saga du Brexit, le Premier ministre britannique Boris Johnson, en acceptant les conditions de l'Union européenne sur le règlement de la question nord-irlandaise, a ouvert la voie à un assouplissement des négociations tenaces après le Brexit.